Buying books: hard copy or its ebook version?
5
Jan
2010
Ever since the Amazon Kindle came out and the popularity of ebooks rose, the dilemma of whether to buy hard copies of books or their ebook equivalent became a more pronounced challenge for me.
The advantages of getting the ebook version of a book I like would be the following:
- Quicker acquisition – Kindle or other ebooks could easily be downloaded over the web and on to my PC or to my future Amazon Kindle device.
It saves up on shipping costs and from the greedy Customs people in my country.
- Lower price – Naturally, ebooks are almost 50% cheaper compared to their printed counterparts, sometimes ebooks are downloadable for free.
- Space saver – To date I have approximately 90 books at home and already, I’m starting to see the need to have more space for additional book shelves to place them all. This is a non-issue with eBooks, I could store a thousand in my PC or future Kindle device.
- Friendlier to trees – Most would say that ebooks are more eco-friendly compared to printed ones because they consume no paper, ink and other packaging materials. However, ebooks are electronic in nature thus requiring electricity to read which in turn burns up fossil fuels so the saved trees could be outweighed by the amount of carbon produced.
On the other hand, a printed book gives you the following goodies:
- Books are personal – The magical feeling of holding a book is sometimes just indescribable. The smell, texture and weight of a book adds another dimension to the reading experience. You get nothing of this from eBooks even when you’re using a Kindle device.
- Books are social – Books can shared with your friends, classmates and fellow bibliophiles. Most often, a great amount of books read by someone came to him by borrowing or swapping it with others. You can’t do that with ebooks because of the restrictive digital rights management software/technologies or your friend must have a PC or a ebook reader in order to read it.
- Books grow in value over time – The older a book the more precious it becomes both in sentimental and monetary values, especially rare and out-of-print books. One dream I have is to leave behind a library of books to my grandchildren and no ebook can replace a printed one in achieving this dream.
At present, and after looking back on what I’ve written so far, it’s kind of obvious that I’m leaning towards getting the printed books over their ebook versions. Though I confess that the price difference is what’s keeping me torn in between.
What’s your take on the matter? Do you face the same dilemma? Share your thoughts on comments below.
4 Responses to Buying books: hard copy or its ebook version?
Patrick
January 7th, 2010 at 2:50 pm
“Quicker acquisition”
This isn’t an issue for me. There’s a multitude of bookstores everywhere I go.
“Lower price”
Really? I thought one of the main complaints right now with ebooks are that they aren’t that cheaper than the paper version. Considering they are delivered electronically and no tree is killed in their production, ebooks should be very very cheap not just have a lower price.
“Space saver”
That’s why there are book swaps. But yeah, personally (with a few exceptions) I hate giving a book away.
“Friendlier to trees”
This one is debatable and I think it’s unfair to call one more green unless a study is conducted.
I actually have another article still in the drafts regarding this issue but I’m holding it for a while lest my readers think I’m so anti-ereader. Haha!
Edward
January 14th, 2010 at 9:17 pm
Sometimes I use an e-reader because I like an option that it has having a black background and having choice of fonts.
Though i agree with your arguments that a physical book has a different appeal. You can share it, you can touch it. Though It felt different when I really liked my e-reader.
GH
July 5th, 2010 at 12:56 am
A couple of other disadvantages to ebooks only.
Technology changes: There is still a risk that sometime in the future the technology changes and the ebooks available today may not be readable in the future; i.e. VHS, cassettes, etc.
Book banning: If any types of books are banned, it would be easier to eliminate the ebook version as compared to the physical version which can be hidden, moved to another location, etc. Ok so you might say this will never happen! Really, many school districts already ban some books like catcher in the rye, Tom Soyer, Huckleberry Fin, etc. Also, some of the recent Supreme Court nominees and individuals in the adminstration believe the gov has the ability to limit books who do not communicate the truth, or taken other positions.
In another aspect, I’m not sure why ebooks are the same price as physical copies anyway, there is not cost of distribution (or as much), no printing costs, no inventory costs, etc. eBooks should be substantially less.
Yet another question, why don’t the distribution offer the option to download the ebook version if you buy the physical copy, or even offer a bundle option (physical copy and ebook) and if they don’t want to include the ebook version for free, at least charge a nominal amount (less than $5). This will then satisfy those who want a physical copy but may also want the ebook version for travel.
pearlie
July 8th, 2010 at 12:01 pm
“Lower price”
I agree with Patrick — I seem to notice that e-books aren’t any cheaper.
“Space saver”
True but the risk of keeping e-books are higher. The moment the harddisk goes down – that’s it, unless you still have access to the accounts where you can download them again.
The only reason why I would get an e-book would be the accessibility to the text and the availability of a search function, since I require textbooks to do my assignments. And yes, the other reason would be that I can actually cart 100s of such textbooks wherever I go in my notebook computer. Can’t do that with printed books – the most I can carry along with me is 2, 3 is pushing it.
The reasons though to stick to printed books are that they are personal, I can write on it, I can hug and I can show it off
But more often than not, the accessibility, convenience and search function trumps it all. And now I have a dilemma – should I spend extra to get the e-books when I already have the printed copies sitting on my shelves.